Motortrades Insight Magazine Online

Putting restrictions on young drivers can make them safer, says RAC Foundation

Ref:A0503
Published: 17 July 2013

learner driver


Placing conditions on the licences of young drivers could reduce fatal accidents amongst this group by more than a half.


One in five young drivers (17-24 year-olds) will have an accident within six months of passing their test and 1,552 young drivers were killed or seriously injured on Britain''s roads in 2011 - more than four every day.


Novice young drivers are at particular risk because of their lack of experience – which to varying degrees affects new drivers of all ages – and also the biological and behavioural characteristics of youth.


The introduction of a graduated licensing system - including restrictions on night-time driving and the number of passengers - would allow young drivers to gain invaluable experience in safer circumstances. 


Research by the RAC Foundation of graduated licensing schemes in other countries shows fatal collisions for this age group falling by between 9 per cent to 60 per cent and overall casualties being cut by 5 per cent to 32 per cent, depending on the range of measures implemented.


Young drivers make up 25 per cent of all those drivers killed or seriously injured on the roads annually, but only account for 8 per cent of licence holders. They also drive less than older licence holders.


Yet the evidence shows that risk reduces quickly as experience is gained. Studies have found that the first 1,000 miles of driving may be the most important in terms of reducing collision risk.


The RAC Foundation study - Young driver safety: solutions to an age-old problem, authored by Foundation staff members Elizabeth Box and Ivo Wengraf - looked at evidence from several countries with graduated licensing including America, Australia, Canada, and New Zealand.


As part of an overhaul of how young people learn to drive, the RAC Foundation is calling for a three-stage process. It will include a one-year minimum learning period during which they would need to have experience of driving in a variety of circumstances, such as during the winter and in darkness. It would also include a one-year post-test period during which there are passenger restrictions and conditions for late-night driving. And finally, it would mean a final full licence with a two year probationary period (which currently exists and during which if a driver receives six penalty points they have to take a retest).


The Foundation also backs a reduction in the drink-drive limit for all drivers to a maximum blood alcohol content of 50mg/100ml (down from the existing 80mg/100ml). This would be of greatest safety benefit to younger drivers, with knock-on benefits for the rest of the driving population.


Here in the UK, the Northern Ireland Assembly is due to bring in legislation in the autumn to improve a graduated licensing scheme which is already in place.


The RAC Foundation research is published as the Government prepares to publish a consultation on young driver safety.


Professor Stephen Glaister, director of the RAC Foundation, said: “Young people are four times more likely to die in a road accident than as a result of drink or drugs. Yet, as a society we seem to turn a blind eye to the carnage. If this was any other area of public health there would be an outcry.


“Circumstances conspire against young drivers. Their youth and lack of experience create a deadly mix which means one in five will have an accident within the first six months of passing their test.


“Our research shows that putting certain restrictions on young drivers allows them to rapidly build up live-saving experience in the safest possible way. Putting a firm number on casualty reduction is hard because of the pick and mix approach to graduate licensing. But the evidence suggests that a full package of measures could reduce fatalities by anything up to 60 per cent.


“Some will complain that these proposals are paternalistic and limit people''s freedom. This is nonsense. We should all have an interest in preserving young drivers'' lives rather than exposing them to undue risk at the stage of their driving careers where they are most vulnerable. This is about ensuring their long term safety and mobility. Not curtailing it.”

Subscribe to MotorTrades insight
MotorTrades Insight are now official news providers for NewsNow.

Top Stories // This Week

michael-schumachers-benetton-b191-among-prestigious-cars-to-be-auctioned-offMichael Schumacher's Benetton B191 among prestigious cars to be auctioned off.  BMW AFM 328 Roadster ex Günther Bechem - German GP.The car in which seven time World Champion Michael Schumacher scored his first ever Grand Prix points is to be auctioned at COYS’ sale in Nürburgri... pepe-reina-set-to-splash-out-on-new-ferrari-or-lamborghini-after-shock-loan-move-to-napoliPepe Reina set to splash out on new Ferrari or Lamborghini after shock loan move to Napoli.  Liverpool legend Pepe Reina could be set to splash out on a brand new top-of-the-range Ferrari or Lamborghini, after his shock loan move to Napoli. The Spanish international, who has been loyal... germanys-313mpg-volkswagen-xl1-makes-london-debut-on-its-way-to-coronation-festivalGermany’s 313mpg Volkswagen XL1 makes London debut on its way to Coronation Festival.  Volkswagen’s futuristic XL1, the world’s most fuel-efficient production hybrid car, took to the streets of the capital yesterday.The two-seat diesel-electric hybrid, which achieves a fuel consumptio... the-automotive-paint-industry-challenge-europes-difficult-economy-encourages-basf-to-aims-for-considerable-growth-in-asia-especially-chinaThe Automotive Paint Industry Challenge: Europe’s ‘difficult economy’ encourages BASF to aims for ‘considerable gro.  The automotive paint industry is being impacted by the difficult economic and financial situation, according to one of the world’s leading manufacturers of vehicle paints and coatings. Speaking... gorgeous-jaguar-c-x75-makes-surprise-public-debut-at-goodwoodGorgeous Jaguar C-X75 makes surprise public debut at Goodwood.  The Jaguar C-X75 is set to make a surprise public dynamic debut today at Goodwood Festival of Speed. The prototype hypercar, one of only five development and test cars in existence,  will ... salon-priv-to-host-hyper-car-lawn-this-september-including-the-pagani-huayra-and-koenigsegg-agera-rSalon Privé to host 'hyper car lawn' this September including the Pagani Huayra and Koenigsegg Agera R.  Salon Privé has announced a new addition to the show for 2013 – a stunning and unrivalled-in-the-UK collection of ''hyper cars''.The first manufacturers to sign up to this new collection with their ... tottenham-hotspurs-roberto-soldado-set-to-buy-aston-martin-volante-to-celebrate-264m-move-as-spurs-aim-to-win-premier-leagueTottenham Hotspur's Roberto Soldado set to buy Aston Martin Volante to celebrate £26.4m move as Spurs aim to win Pr.  Roberto Soldado has been signed to move to North London and join Tottenham Hotspur next season for a bargain £26.4m, but he'll be aiming to win more than simply titles and screamer goals. Having sco... ferrari-shows-true-speed-at-goodwoods-20th-anniversaryFerrari shows true speed at Goodwood's 20th Anniversary.  Although the excitement of the 20th Anniversary of the Goodwood Festival of Speed is over for another year, Ferrari fans will have many memories on which to reflect until next year’s event. Ferrari ... yvan-muller-joins-sebastien-loeb-at-citroen-racing-for-wtcc-in-2014Yvan Muller joins Sebastien Loeb at Citroen Racing for WTCC in 2014.  Citroën Racing has recruited Yvan Muller as part of its World Touring Car Championship team. The French driver, a three-time world champion, will drive one of the Citroën C-Elysée WTCC cars tha... goodwood-festival-of-speed-pictures-from-day-oneGoodwood Festival of Speed: Pictures from Day One.  With the Goodwood Festival of Speed having kicked off in style today, many people will be looking forward to the weekend when the festival will be at its busiest. Here, we provide you with a wi... the-next-generation-supercar-honda-nsx-prototype-wows-ohio-crowdsThe Next-Generation Supercar: Honda NSX prototype wows Ohio crowds.  The Honda NSX prototype lapped the 2.4-mile Mid-Ohio Sports Car Course in Lexington, Ohio, just prior to the running of the Honda Indy 200, showcasing the steady progress being made toward the plann... 

Cookies on Motortrades Insight

Like many popular websites, Motortrades Insight uses some third party widgets that may set and may have already set cookies, for example the Twitter feed on our homepage.
For more information see our cookie policy. By clicking close and continue you agree to our use of cookies.